Wed, 29 Apr 2026 15:48:41 +0000

You Won’t Believe What ‘All’s Fair’ Means at Metacritic’s Shocking New Rule! In a move that has left gamers and critics alike stunned, Metacritic has introduced a controversial new rule under its All’s Fair policy that redefines how reviews and scores are handled on its platform. Once seen as an authoritative voice in gaming journalism, Metacritic’s latest shift has sparked debates about fairness, transparency, and the integrity of video game critiques. ### What Is the New ‘All’s Fair’ Rule? At a glance, the rule claims to enforce “All’s Fair” principles by allowing users and publishers to manipulate review scores—ostensibly to eliminate bias or accommodate “contextual factors” such as developer relationships, fair competition, or even fan sentiment. While framed as a move toward balance, many interpret this as an oversold loosening of editorial standards, potentially opening the door to arbitrary scoring adjustments.