Do Movie Writers Steal Their Best Scenes? Saw vs. Film Reveals the Truth!

Fri, 01 May 2026 14:27:57 +0000

Do Movie Writers Steal Their Best Scenes? Saw vs. Film Reveals the Truth When fans dissect iconic horror scenes—like the famous “bucket.”
rashes from Saw—they often wonder: Where does the brilliance come from? Is it original genius, careful homage, or outright plagiarism? With film cross-analyses increasingly shedding light on screenwriting practices, it’s time to explore whether movie writers truly lift their most memorable moments from other films—or if creativity still reigns supreme in the craft of storytelling. ### The Case of Saw’s Most Memorable Scenes The Saw franchise has long been debated for its graphic tension and twisty plot mechanics. Yet beneath its shocking rules and brutal puzzles lies a recurring theme: several of its most shocking scenes echo stories told before in film and theater. Take, for example, the intense moment when the “bucket falls” or the emotional confrontations in Saw II and Saw III. These scenes share striking similarities with earlier horror tropes, especially in courtroom drama and revenge thriller circles.